Best BBQ on the Beach

Words by Audrey Johnson

Photos by Todd Douglas

DSC00600_Danny Consenzi_30AA.jpg

Restaurateur Danny Cosenzi opened his first restaurant, Grappa, to much fanfare. “It won best new restaurant in Atlanta in 1998,” he says. “Dinner only. Small entity. Real tight-knit family.”

After selling Grappa, he landed at The Palm Atlanta, the oldest family-owned steakhouse in the country. The Atlanta institution has been around since 1926. That's where Danny met his wife Monica. Soon after, Danny began running operations for The Palm and traveling frequently to locations across the country.

When the Cosenzis became parents, they moved to Michigan to be near Monica’s family. Danny began running a farm-to-table concept dubbed Toasted Oak Grill & Market. During his tenure there, the restaurant was selected do a James Beard dinner in New York. “All the food we did was from Michigan. We wanted to stay true to the region. We even did Michigan wines,” he says.

Michigan was quite a change after spending 16 years in Atlanta, and Danny and Monica were itching to get back to the South. The Cosenzis and their friends (turned business partners) frequented 30A, a beach road along Florida’s Emerald Coast, through the major stages of life: engagements, weddings, and parenthood. So, when Danny began looking for a restaurant to buy in South Walton, Florida, he knew he wanted to create a place where the staff felt like family.

So how did he become a restaurateur with two concepts on opposite ends of the spectrum? On one hand is Restaurant Paradis, the sophisticated sister in Rosemary Beach. And on the other is the approachable bearded cousin known as Back Beach Barbecue. What could possibly be the tie that binds them? In a word: family. “We’re a bit of a dysfunctional family that still supports one another,” Danny jokes.

Good Grit: How did you come to own Restaurant Paradis?

“About five years ago, my business partner told me there was an opportunity we should go explore in Rosemary Beach. So we came down and had dinner at Restaurant Paradis. We had all these grandiose ideas. We were thinking, ‘If we need to, whatever restaurants we look at, we’ll flip; I had already written menus. We went into Paradis, had dinner, and met some of the staff. We said, ‘Don’t change a thing.’ If something works, it works. It was good timing and a good opportunity for us. I knew I wanted to create a family. This is super important to me. What Paradis already had was that.”

GG: How did you  collaborate on the concept for Back Beach Barbecue?

“My running joke is, ‘I love barbecue forever.’ I was always sitting with the idea. “I took my chef, Mark Eichin, down to Austin, and in two days we did like eight barbecue places. A couple of people knew we were coming and took us right to the back. So we were in the pits back there with these guys. We 100 percent copied Texas Barbecue. All they do is put the seasoning on the meat—black pepper, kosher salt, some savory and other seasonings. They leave it exactly the way it should be and serve one person at a time. So you’re eating fresh meat cut right in front of you.

“When we got back home, I started looking for a free-standing location, and then I started looking for smokers. I had the menu done. If you look at the menu, it's pretty simple. Chef Mark and the pit master, Shane Kirkland, worked on the side recipes and created the spice.”

GG: What sets Back Beach Barbecue apart from other barbecue concepts in Panama City Beach?

“When we came back from Austin, I didn't know what smokers to use. I did a lot of research and I came across the line of Lang BBQ Smokers out of Nahunta, Georgia. Ben Lang is the coolest guy. He doesn’t even call them smokers; he calls them cookers. We have three of his smokers out in front and everything gets cooked on them except for coleslaw, potato salad, and collard greens. Even the mac and cheese—we take the blocks of Velveeta and we smoke them until they turn into a gooey mess and we make a sauce with it.

“The thing I'm probably the most proud of is that the cookers are true stick-burning. There’s no gas. A lot of barbecue restaurants do really good barbecue and there's wood in their cookers, but there's a gas emission that controls the temperature. With ours you never know what you're gonna get when you try to light it. Sometimes it’s not that easy with the elements.

DSC00439_Danny Consenzi_30Aa.jpg

GG: Back Beach Barbecue is a restaurant, a food truck, and a catering company. How do you balance all three?

Day planners. I’ve got to have a planner. Every single day something is going on. You’ve just got to be all over it. Thankfully, with the staff that I have, they take good care. I have a routine. I’m at Restaurant Paradis by 7:30 in the morning when nobody's there, so I can get everything laid out and organized. We do everything very personal, too. I trust the staff enough to say, ‘This is what we’ve got. How do we want to handle it?’”

GG: What aspect of being a restaurateur do you love the most?

At this stage, creating that personal touch to take care of the guest. Restaurant Paradis is a gift. Monica and I are so blessed. The riches you get from having a close-knit staff are amazing. If you read the reviews in-depth, like an owner would, guests talk about the attention to detail. At 5 o’clock the show goes on. I’m proud—super proud—of what the staff does. They’re more like a family, and family is the most important thing.